NewsWatch NewsWatch
← Today

Early voting tops 43 million as DOJ ballot fights land in California and Alaska courts

Oct 31, 14:07 EDT · 160 articles assessed ·written by claude-opus-5

In short

  • AP: 43M+ early ballots cast five days out; Texas up ~50% at 6.3M, South Carolina up 83%
  • 9th Circuit panel rules 2-1 against DOJ bid to set aside ~20,000 disputed California ballots
  • Judge Trina Thompson issues TRO barring DOJ/DHS threats to prosecute election workers, citing likely VRA breach
  • Alaska US attorney confirms criminal probe into same-name Senate 'spoiler'; dozens of DOJ subpoenas reported
  • Pope Leo XIV reported to have mailed an Illinois ballot; CNN and Vatican News among outlets carrying it
  • 156 of 160 articles assessed accurate, none flagged fabricated — but many verdicts rest on feed summaries

The full briefing

Turnout and litigation dominated the cycle four days out from the November 3 midterms. An Associated Press data analysis, carried by the Chicago Tribune, PBS and NPR, reported more than 43 million early ballots cast nationwide, running well ahead of 2022: roughly a 50 percent jump in Texas to 6.3 million, increases above 30 percent in Maine, Michigan, North Carolina and Kansas, and 83 percent in South Carolina. The Texas numbers were framed against the Paxton-Talarico Senate race and the Abbott-Hinojosa governor's contest. Service journalism ran alongside it: NPR's member-station voter-guide directory was the single most widely carried item of the day, and AP's Decision Notes previewed Minnesota's open governor and Senate races.

The courts produced the sharpest news. A 9th Circuit panel ruled 2-1 against the Justice Department's request that California set aside about 20,000 ballots from voters the administration alleges may not be citizens, finding DOJ had not met the burden for an injunction pending appeal; CBS News, NBC and Al Jazeera carried it. The same day, U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson was reported to have issued a temporary restraining order barring DOJ and DHS from threatening election workers with prosecution over those ballots, finding a likely Voting Rights Act violation. Separately, the top federal prosecutor in Alaska confirmed a criminal investigation into an alleged scheme to place a candidate sharing Sen. Dan Sullivan's name on the ballot, with The Hill reporting dozens of DOJ subpoenas and, citing the New York Times, alleging involvement by Mary Peltola's campaign. Elsewhere: a public clash between Michigan Senate nominee Abdul El-Sayed and Rep. Haley Stevens over a Rebellion PAC ad on Israel, Q3 filings showing more than $15 billion raised since early 2025 and a Musk-backed Texas PAC spending over $148 million, and a widely picked-up report that Pope Leo XIV cast a mail ballot in Illinois.

The verification picture was unusually clean: 156 of 160 articles assessed as accurate reporting, four as mixed, and nothing flagged as fabricated or machine-generated. That is worth reading carefully rather than celebrating. Many of these verdicts carry confidence in the 0.60-0.78 range and lean on outlet identity, byline conventions and wire provenance rather than claim-by-claim checking, because the underlying 2026 events sit past what the checker can independently verify. A substantial share of items — the Hill subpoena story, the Washington Times Alaska piece, the CNN papal ballot item, the Fox News Leavitt teaser, the Chicago Defender midterm preview — were assessed from RSS summaries alone, meaning any distortion inside the full body would not have been visible.

Two patterns deserve flagging. First, corroboration counts are inflated by syndication: AP copy appearing on PBS, U.S. News and WTOP, or an NPR newsletter echoed by a member station, does not constitute independent confirmation, and several assessments said so explicitly. Second, the papal-ballot story is the clearest thin-sourcing case — the core event was carried by multiple major outlets, but the most striking supporting detail, surgery to remove a cancerous lung tumor, traces to TMZ alone, and one aggregator garbled the USCCB's name and misattributed a quote. The Washington Examiner's Michigan piece asserted that Jewish leaders condemned the Rebellion PAC ad as antisemitic without naming any. Watch for results-page shells like MassLive's filling with live numbers, for whether the Alaska investigation produces named defendants, and for how the California ballot litigation moves before Tuesday.

Verdict split for this briefing

98%
Accurate 98% Mixed 2% Fabricated 0%

Every verdict behind this briefing is an automated assessment with a stated confidence, not a determination of fact. What we can and cannot measure →